An evaluation of major life issues that challenge God’s existence.
A presentation of his actual role within human suffering and evil.
Firstly, I think that the greatest error of all is to theorise that God himself deliberately creates all suffering and evil, i.e. that they are the ‘will of God’. It just does not make sense with what we are told of God’s loving nature in the Bible. (The “Will of God” is explained in the article of that name.)
Even so, if there is a God who is supposed to be good, why is there so much suffering and evil in the world? Without doubt, it is a difficult, difficult question, this one. Many thoughts arise when assessing it. Is there any way God could have designed things differently? Importantly, could the world and we human beings be designed in ways that would reduce or even eliminate suffering and evil?
Ultimately, this issue of suffering and evil does lead us to question God’s role in relation to these issues. And also what should be our response to them.
2. MY WISH LIST
A ‘mere mortal’ like me can only guess what I would have done. That is, if I had the responsibility for planning the way the world should be. Like anyone else I have the right to use my imagination, eh?
Could I have left suffering and evil completely out of the specifications?
If not, could I design a world where no child would suffer physical pain or death? Better still, a world where everybody would live perfectly healthy and happy lives until at least one hundred years of age? The random effects of disease and genetic disorders would be no more.
And could I prevent horrifying accidents from happening? Could an invisible barrier be placed between all people and objects of possible injury or death, no matter what risks they or others took with their bodies?
What about stopping natural disasters from harming humans? Could I leave them – earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, hurricanes, tornadoes, cyclones and even tsunamis – out of the grand design? There would be no storms and the sea could look like a millpond all the time … yes!
Is there any way I could program people so that nobody would be cruel to others?
If everything else failed, and we asked through ‘faith’, then could God unleash miracles on all those who are suffering?
My wish list seems to cover ‘most of the angles’ doesn’t it?
3. REALITY CHECK
But, you know, when I analyse my specifications above I do find faults with them. I do come from an auditing background you see. (To read about the ‘who’, ‘how’ and ‘why’ of this website please click here.)
3.1 Would the world look fake?
If I did design such a world where accidents, ill health and threatening natural conditions were absent, how could I expect it all to look real? Yes, laws of cause and effect must be in this world to make it appear that way. We would all accept that ‘reality’ must look real, by virtue of its title.
If God continually muddled in the space/ time continuum, to alter the outcome of all potentially dangerous events, then we would have noticeable flow-on effects in our daily lives. Resulting warps in the ‘continuum’ could for example cause: moving objects to stop in their tracks; landscape changes; people to recover overnight from serious illness or disease, without any medical help. It would not matter what we ate or drank or inhaled or injected because our bodies would recover from all forms of abuse.
Life, as we know it, would be so visibly different. In fact, we would have to acknowledge a considerable ‘force’ existing beneath reality. In fact, God’s existence would become so very clear to us all. As explained in the article, “Why is God invisible?” that does not sit well with his actual needs.
Surely then, above all else within my plan for humankind’s habitat, nature would have to be seen as running its own course rather than the case as described above. If this is true, then its unfortunate impact on our health and the environment in which we live will have to remain with us.
3.2 Dangers of overruling nature
As a twenty first century human being, I also understand that many ‘natural disasters’ are by-products of the underlying conditions needed on this planet to support complex life forms, such as ourselves. To take them away would give us less than the ideal planet that we need.
An expansion of this line of reasoning is included in the article, “Life, the universe and everything” (under Heading 4). As an example, the Earth’s molten centre, and plate tectonics (moving continents), are essential elements in the mix of conditions actually required by our living planet. Unfortunately, unavoidable side effects of these elements are earthquakes and tsunamis as examples.
3.3 Outcome of overruling free will
From the human perspective too, our free will means that people will more than likely continue to harm themselves and other people, no matter what! Human greed, hatred, uncontrolled anger and intolerance are major contributors to evil.
In other words, if we are to have free will, then we must all suffer the consequences. Otherwise, we would only be programmed robots. Not a good alternative at all!
3.4 Drawbacks of everyday miracles
And what of miracles that might overcome our suffering? They still happen, don’t they? If we have faith, then surely … ? Although, in fact, I do know that ‘miracles‘ still happen – that is the occasional overriding of the laws of cause and effect by God, at our request – they will always be rare in the ‘scheme of things’.
Miracles are usually special ‘one offs’ used by God to build up his Church and individuals within it. Sadly, we must remember that if life was to be a continual ‘bed of roses’ for all of us we would never become the mature spiritual beings intended by God; beings who are to spend eternity with him after leaving our physical existences behind. Please see the verse, Romans 8:18 in the Bible.
(Present day miracles are discussed in the article, “Experiencing the Holy Spirit”.)
4. GOD’S ROLE IN SUFFERING AND EVIL
So, what of God’s role in human suffering? I have experienced enough physical pain (as a cancer survivor) and emotional pain (loss of a son) in my life to understand the concepts of this article. Through my own experiences I recognise that suffering and life are ‘intertwined’ with each other. I do not blame God for that pain in my life.
4.1 The one true constant in our lives
As I have already implied, it appears that ‘cause and effect’, and chance, are essential in the ‘equation’ of existence – to make it all real. Science can often tell us how these things happen. However the actual “why” seems to be beyond the best of us human beings a lot of the time. One book of the Christian Bible, “Ecclesiastes”, points out the irony of life: the misery and obvious injustices that so many people suffer. It also points out the senselessness of us trying to understand why. The first chapter introduces the flavour of ‘futility’ within life.
says the Teacher.
Everything is meaningless.”
God is offered by the Book’s author as the one true ‘constant’ in our lives that we can rely on.
Again, in the ‘scheme of things’, it is necessary to look at God’s role in our pain and suffering (physical and emotional). He is not there to continually interfere with the ‘rolling dice’ of chance, that is evident as nature runs its course. That is, so that we can accept reality for what it is. And we can lead lives based on our rational decisions. Indeed, God’s primary role is one of support and comfort; helping us to ‘grow’ to successfully face hardship – and indirectly to encourage us to strengthen our relationship with him as the “the one true constant” mentioned above.
4.2 He is with us in our suffering
In fact, God is closer to us in our suffering than we might first think. We must not take the Biblical statement [Acts 17:28] lightly – “For in him we live and move and have our being.” How can God not know when we suffer? Additionally, God is absolutely and completely linked to our suffering in an incredible way, i.e. at the very ‘causation’ of our own being’s existence (see the article “So, what is God”). He therefore knows of our pain from whatever source, physical or emotional.
Most importantly too, in the ‘person’ of Jesus, God experienced extreme physical and emotional pain as a human being for himself. Of course I am referring to Jesus’ torture and eventual death by crucifixion. Yes, God knows exactly what we are going through.
God is literally there to enfold us with his loving support and comforting, if we deliberately open ourselves, and engage with him. He is always ready and waiting! Please also read the article, “God during hard times” for an explanation of how he is actually ready to assist us when we are in that position.
4.3 God is not responsible for evil
In relation to evil, in my view at least, it is wrong to blame God for its creation.
Rather, evil is born in the minds of humankind. It is fanned by the ‘dark power’ that opposes God’s goodness. (A subject that has great authenticity in my mind, but is outside the scope of this website.)
5. OUR RESPONSE TO SUFFERING AND EVIL
The Bible encourages us to make the most of our lives: that is accept misfortune when it occurs, but also ensure that we fully appreciate joy in life when it comes our way.
5.1 Find balance in our lives
It is also our responsibility to find that ideal balance. Along with being faithful to God and contributing positively towards our families and the greater human community on Earth, we should also find time for joy. We need to find time for appreciating the so-called simple things of life. It is not wise to work, work, work for example, to later find when life turns a ‘hard corner’ that we have not enjoyed our opportunities. (Note however, that I am not suggesting an empty life of party, party, party either!)
5.2 Use of Christian ‘hope’
But when suffering does actually occur in our lives, Christianity offers us the concept of “Hope” (Romans 15:13). Through hope we can approach suffering differently. As I have already advised, God will be there during hard times! ‘Hope’ for Christians is itself perfectly highlighted in the knowledge that although God in the person of Jesus died after suffering on the cross, he was resurrected after that death. (Christians believe that they will eventually have life with God after death, through God’s power of love, as in Jesus’ example.)
Christian hope is effectively enabled by God’s transforming power of love. This ‘hope’ is about opening one’s situation to God in full faith and trust. Love, support, guidance, personal inner strength are all available from him. As far as this article is concerned, hope fuels the present and resists the despair that often arises with suffering. Hope, most importantly, has the ability to give us rest, even if nothing more is available today! Hope can in fact ease the weight of whatever faces us right now, tomorrow or years into the future.
I have come across Christians who seem to ‘weather’ these terrible life situations well. The usefulness of Christian hope, when suffering, was brought home to me by a woman very special to my wife and me. She suffers from advanced Motor Neuron Disease and successfully utilises Christian ‘hope’ to face each new day of that suffering; to get through it with still some quality of life. The woman’s husband is incidentally also a guiding light to me, such is the unending loving care and support that he devotes to her. I can absolutely assure you that this woman, further along the road of life than my wife and me, does not apportion any blame for her life situation upon God!
5.3 Perspective on life and death
Remember also that our present physical lives are minuscule in length when compared with Heaven’s eternity, which is the Biblical promise to the faithful (at a minimum) at life’s end. That is the ultimate reward for our Christian hope.
5.4 Christian response to evil
And finally what should our response to evil be? Christians are called to stand up in peaceful protest to resist the evil that is directed by our fellow human beings towards those vulnerable in society, both in our own countries and throughout the world.
As I have already alluded, I do know that God’s presence can become both more needed, and obvious, during times of suffering than when ‘the good times roll’. From my own experience, these hard times will draw us believers closer to the Lord and encourage us to mature spiritually. So, something positive can occur out of suffering.
Despite all the facts though, I must be honest here and say that I do still find the question “why?”, in regard to human suffering, hard to answer sometimes. I also admit that the suffering of others can strain my relationship with God a bit at times … And I do complain to him! But it never throws my faith into doubt. I have experienced too much of his presence in my life, and witnessed it in the lives of others, for that to happen. (Even then, I know that doubt is not always a bad thing anyway.)
I know too that I will never come close to having God’s level of wisdom, when it comes to human suffering.
Importantly, we must remember that hope sits at the core of our ability to handle the suffering that comes our way in life. Hope transforms! It can even be applied through prayer and human involvement to combat evil in this world.
If you wish to know more about ‘what’ God actually is, then access the article, “So, what is God?”. The final section of the website explains Christianity and presents an understanding of ‘who’ God is. Christianity offers a whole-of-life philosophy that certainly deals effectively with suffering and evil. Finally, if you would like guidance on how to know whether God actually exists, then access the article, “Can I believe in God?”.
Join our facebook discussions, please.